Maybe it’s me. I’ve always considered myself a hopeless romantic, who believes in poetry and the narcotic bliss of love, and dancing in the rain. I’m a dude, so for all intents and purposes, I’m not meant to like chick flicks. We’re supposed to get dragged kicking and screaming to these odious romantic comedies and then sit there scowling, while we then drag our dearhearts to horror and action flicks and watch blood flow like wine.
This year, I watched Enchanted and loved it. Fucking loved every moment of that sparkling film. The Princess Bride and When Harry Met Sally, it doesn’t get much better than Rob Reiner in his heyday. And I thought Legally Blonde was magnificent. So it is possible for me to like romantic comedies. I just can’t understand how women allow themselves to be represented by this latest flock of crap.
Hollywood’s been slapping women in the face with its collective dick over the last few months by throwing these poorly manufactured explotation flicks at them. The last romantic comedy that seemed to move anyone to joy was Knocked Up. So, it was with the trudge of a red shirted ensign that I went to my inevitable doom in what can only be deemed payback for the unholy miasma of crap I’ve exposed loving Higginbottom to.
27 Dresses was akin to watching an overweight bridesmaid squeezed into her gown: unpleasant to look at, awkwardly forced, blatantly and poorly manufactured, uncomfortably funny at time, and horribly misused. It was as if this was written by manatees with a penchant for White Zinfandel.
Katherine Heigl is a perpetual bridesmaid, one who constantly helps her friends out with their weddings. The movie opens with her zipping back and forth from two wedding receptions in a cab in New York. She’s got a hopeless crush on her boss George (Edward Burns) who’s an entrepreneur for an outdoor catalog. Her model sister Tess (Malin Ackerman) comes to town and her and the boss instantly fall in love and decide to get married. Of course, Heigl has to plan the whole wedding. Enter convenient love interest Kevin (James Marsden) who stalks her until she agrees to see him. Oh, but he also happens to be the newspaper writer whose writing she gushes over and saves. How convenient.
27 Dresses could have been a better movie. It really had potential, but it just sort of got the train of the gown stuck in the door and couldn’t go anywhere. Punching plot holes in chick flicks is akin to pointing out the logistics of character development in a slasher flick, but I think it’s about high time we started demanding more from romantic comedy instead of this formulaic hash.
First of all, I don’t care how wedding obsessed this chick is, she wouldn’t be going to two weddings on the same day. Not in New York, not in a cab cross town. Not going back and forth. It actually makes her really frightening and desperate. There’s always sort of this nervous edge of stalker/maniac in romantic comedy. Like mysteriously showing up at places to talk to strangers, or memorizing details of a non-spouse’s life, or offering to go out for “just a drink”. What’s the alternative? No, no, we don’t have to fuck until the middle act, right now we just have to hate each other. I’m going to start asking people to go out for “just a cheeseburger and a handjob.” What? Work off those calories.
The movie would totally derail characters that they worked so hard not to set up properly in the first place. Heigl shows such hatred and loathing for Kevin, when they finally do hook up, it seems so trite and forced. I’ve sung in bars before. I’ve led bars in song. You never, NEVER, sing the same song twice. Not in a row, that’s for goddamn sure. I don’t know where these fuckers travel. Apparently the magical bar that appears only during fierce monsoons in upstate New York on the side of the road in the middle of nowhere where people can just have drunken hate sex in cars.
Plus, they set up this stupid love triangle, where not only does Heigl’s character have to watch her dipshit sister lie her way into the Dockers of the man she craves, but then she has to sit there and watch the relationship blossom like she some sort of melancholy chaffeur getting kicked in the back of the head while the “master” gives it to the chambermaid in the backseat. Obviously, it’s the screenwriter’s sloppy way of demonstrating how selfish the sister is and how maniac Heigl is. She can’t say no. She’ll plan the perfect wedding for her cunt sister to the man she wants, because she loves WEDDINGS THAT MUCH. That’s not just stupid, that’s borderline personality disorder.
The scene that made me angriest took place in some shitty shop, where Heigl’s character has to go and register her sister and her boss for their gifts. Since they’ve got better things to do like…something I guess, I don’t know. So Kevin tags along because he’s doing a story on the wedding. I’m just pretending that the entire newspaper part of the story didn’t happen. It was so tacked on and used to ill effect it mine as well have been cut from the movie. During their exchange, it gets revealed that Kevin’s so bitter and cynical about weddings (even though he writes the beautiful pieces in the New York Journal about the weddings) because…gasp, shock…he went through a bitter divorce. That’s all we hear about it. That’s it. That’s why, even though he dances and pines with all the fervor of a typical romantic comedy asshole, he’s not really into the whole wedding thing. So, as a caveat, they decide to register the worst gifts for the couple. It cuts.
That’s what I mean! I would have loved to see the bonding scene between them choosing gifts. That would have been perfect, developed the characters, made them interesting. But no, we have to essentially have the Passion of the Bridesmaid as she gets tortured by her cunt sister and her oblvious boss. What a waste. And that’s what the movie keeps doing. It just seems too stupid to realize when it’s doing things right.
Judy Greer is the only bright spot in this. She’s fantastic as the best friend. I now officially forgive her for Cursed. She’s hilarious, and doesn’t deserve to be saddled with this movie. She seems like she wandered in off the set of an awesomer movie to say her lines. That can be the only logical reason for not using her properly in this one.
Edward Burns is criminally terrible as the boss/love interest. He’s the poor man’s Luke Wilson, and the only thing I can buy is that he has no fucking clue about what’s going on around him. But then again, I’ve seen his writer/director work, so I know this is true. And Malin Ackerman must suck the meanest cock in Hollywood to keep getting cast in things. She’s a low-rent Cameron Diaz, and her only talent might be a scapegoat. She’s so bad, she makes the rest of the cast seem Oscar worthy. After seeing her in this, I bought a kitten from six year old standing on a street corner holding a box of kittens just so I could kick it into traffic.
But, maybe I’m just asking to much. Maybe I’m too much of a bitter angry little man to appreciate the subtle nuances. Higginbottom liked it. So like I said, maybe it’s my fault for liking good things.