Because I run an international bi-coastal drug ring, for posterity’s purposes, I am required by Talmudic law to post my selections for the Oscars. For the first time, in I believe EVER, I am actually pretty pleasantly surprised by the selections for the categories. There were of course ones that set me off (Johnny Depp? For reals?) but for the most part, everything was justified. It was actually a great year for movies.
So here are my picks for tonight’s MPAA Final Twenty Four. Because I’m a mouthy tool, I will list who I’ve selected to win, followed by who I’d like to see win. Gentlemen, place your wagers!
BEST LEADING ACTOR
I Chose: Daniel-Day Lewis, There Will Be Blood
Who Should Win: Daniel-Day Lewis, There Will Be Blood
The man just owned this film. He lifted it on his angry Irish shoulders and hoisted that bastard straight through it’s entire 2 hour plus runtime, barreling aside anyone in his way. Higginbottom and I agree that if by some cosmic fuckup he is not selected, he should storm onstage, and beat the other actor to death with the golden statue.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
I Chose: Javier Bardem, No Country for Old Men
Who Should Win: Javier Bardem, No Country for Old Men
I was nervous, thinking these two would have to face off in the Lead Actor category, but then I forgot that the Oscars are as political as a PTA meeting in Brentwood. So, they stayed out each other’s way. And in a year that has a staggeringly, staggeringly good amount of performance for supporting males this year, Javier killed everyone in his path. Though I really would have like to see these two fight each other onstage. Maybe they’ll pull a Rainn Wilson/Philip Seymour Hoffman wrassling match.
BEST LEAD ACTRESS
I Chose: Julie Christie, Away From Her
Who Should Win: Laura Linney, The Savages
This was the one category where I hadn’t seen as many of the films. And as much as I love Ellen Page with the fire of a thousand suns, I just think she’s not earned her credit yet. She’s going to win something, some day. But Laura Linney really deserves an Oscar. And she was very good in The Savages.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
I Chose: Ruby Dee, American Gangster
Who Should Win: Amy Ryan, Gone Baby Gone
Cate Blanchett was a stunt performance; Tilda Swinton was amazing…as Tilda Swinton, the role she plays in every movie; Saoirse Ronan was good, but ask the little girl from Little Miss Sunshine how much we thank heaven for you; and Amy Ryan has been awesome in just about every goddamn thing she’s been in this year. But she’s so good, people forget what movies she’s been in. So Ruby Dee wins. Because she’s an old black lady. And the Oscars love white guilt.
BEST ANIMATED FEATURE
I Chose: Ratatouille
Who Should Win: Ratatouille
Fuck your stupid kids who didn’t like this. Pixar didn’t make it for them. They made it for me. And I loved this movie. Although Persepolis was stylistically much cooler, it just couldn’t even come close to hanging with this film.
ART DIRECTION
I Chose: Sweeney Todd, The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Who Should Win: Sweeney Todd, The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
But it’ll probably go to There Will Be Blood or Atonement, because the Oscar folk love to vote in batches. It helps them not to think. The best part, the only good part of Sweeney Todd was the visuals. It was staggering. It actually made the movie watchable.
BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY
I Chose: There Will Be Blood
Who Should Win: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
Everyone marvels at Paul Thomas Anderson and his ability to frame a long shot. And it’s true, between him and the Coens, they’ve both made landscape paintings of the American Southwest. But honest to God, Julian Schnabel’s camera dude actually captured what it looks like to be paralyzed and only see from one eye. It was fucking haunting.
BEST COSTUME DESIGN
I Chose: Atonement
Who Should Win: La Vie En Rose
Oscar voters love foreign films like white people love Toyota Prui-ui. Especially British ones. And in this category, I really could care less this year.
BEST DIRECTOR
I Chose: Ethan and Joel Coen, No Country for Old Men
Who Should Win: Julian Schnabel, The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
Tonight will be a fight between No Country and Blood. But again, Julian Schnabel did things with this movie that I can’t believe are possible. Using static shots, point of view, and the most effective narration I’ve ever known, he created ART. Nobody has seen this film, and few will. But if it was strong enough, as a foreign film, to stand out of the actual foreign film category, you know it’s gotta be great.
BEST DOCUMENTARY FEATURE
I Chose: Sicko
Who Should Win: King of Kong: A Fistful of Quarters
Yeah, it wasn’t nominated, and Taxi to the Dark Side will probably win. They packed this category full of anti-Iraq films, and so Michael Moore stands alone. And Sicko actually made me really furious at the state of healthcare in this country. It’s definitely biased, and probably inaccurate, but it’s still gall-inducing. It made me stand up and pay attention to the election. Because I am pissed, FURIOUS, that we don’t have some sort of healthcare initiative in America. And it’s all this pudgy hack’s fault.
BEST DOCUMENTARY SHORT
I Chose: Sari’s Mother
Who Should Win: ?
Like the rest of the Academy, I haven’t seen any of the short features. So I just choose based on a whim. Or because the title makes me giggle. Mother = good.
BEST FILM EDITING
I Chose: No Country for Old Men
Who Should Win: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
I’d love to see a Coen sweep, though it’ll probably be There Will Be Blood. And do I need to gush anymore about Diving Bell? I do not.
BEST FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM
I Chose: The Counterfeiters
Who Should Win: Lust, Caution; Persepolis; The Diving Bell and the Butterfly; 4 months, 3 weeks, 2 days and The Kite Runner
This is one of the categories where I am fucking flummoxed. It was as if they said, well, if I saw it over in America, it can’t be foreign. They essentially filled this with random shit, and some film nobody cares about will win, because that’s just how we roll. Hollywood is so elitist, they actually have to choose foreign films even foreign people haven’t seen. I picked Counterfeiters, because it was the only one I heard about, and I wanted to see it, and it’s about World War II. And as Spielberg can attest, the old crowd of Oscar voters loves them some concentration camp stories.
BEST MAKEUP
I Chose: Norbit
Who Should Win: Anyone else.
I threw up a little in my mouth at this. But frankly, the Oscars love controversy and stirring shit up. They have to sit through these 4 hours when they could be drinking. It’s like a particularly long Catholic wedding. You want booze. So you need to amuse yourself. You do crazy shit. That’s how the worst crime against America gets nominated and praised.
BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
I Chose: Atonement
Who Should Win: Into the Wild
I’m banking on the whole we’ll just give it to Atonement where there’s no Country vs. Blood fiasco mentality of the Academy. I honestly didn’t hear a score that impressed me this year moreso that what Eddie Vedder did with Into the Wild. He perfectly captured the damn nature-loving adventure of the movie. But because he was in Pearl Jam, you know, fuck him. Well, There Will Be Blood’s actually irritated me. Everyone was lauding Jonny Greenwood. But as I said in my review, it sounded like he got high and tried to hump a theramin.
ORIGINAL SONG
I Chose: “Falling Slowly”, Once
Who Should Win: “Falling Slowly”, Once
The August Rush song is cute and all, but nobody cared about that movie. ”So Close” must have been a mistake, that never should have been nominated. It’s an AWFUL, AWFUL song. It’s spot should have gone to Eddie Vedder. Who doesn’t deserve to win either. That leaves the two wonderful songs from Enchanted. And since nobody will be able to choose between the two of them: either the Snow White dance number with roaches and pidgeons cleaning a house, or the huge dance number in Central Park, then you get the winner who should win, Once. In an adorable movie, this moment, this song, was so powerful and sweet and captured everything about the movie, it deserves to win. And I LOVED Once.
BEST PICTURE OF THE YEAR
I Chose: No Country for Old Men
Who Should Win: Juno
As has been wisely pointed out on Pajiba!, Juno is going to now suffer, and is beginning to suffer, a painful hipness backlash. Which makes me sad. Because it was such a perfect, awesome movie. Everyone rooted for it, but then when it became bigger than life, everyone started shunning it. It suffered the hipster shun, being hissed at from behind geek-specs and tight sweaters. Which is really sad. But aside from, sigh, Atonement, everyone deserves to be here. I just think No Country is a more palatable film. Though There Will Be Blood will probably win because its so dark and dramatic, the audiences will assume they’re supposed to like it. And No Country will suffer the same Coen backlash they always see. Be like Spielberg, guys. Make a movie about a concentration camp. Then they’ll vote for you!
BEST SHORT FILM — ANIMATED
I Chose: I Met the Walrus
Who Should Win: ?
Didn’t see any. It’s about a kid meeting John Lennon. Beatles = votes.
BEST SHORT FILM — LIVE ACTION
I Chose: The Mozart of Pickpockets
Who Should Win: Yeast
Didn’t see anything. I liked the title. Also I had to give a shout out to my friend’s film, which is playing at SXSW next month. Oscars 2009?
BEST SOUND EDITING/BEST SOUND MIXING
I Chose: No Country for Old Men
Who Should Win: Television viewers.
This is always the point of the night where they let the comedy SHINE, because nobody can care less. Sound is a key element of film, but they are the drummers of the film world. And nobody likes Drummers (take that Wexler, inevitable winner of this years pool!). So it’ll probably go to No Country in a vast sweep.
BEST VISUAL EFFECTS
I Chose: Transformers
Who Should Win: Beowulf
Beowulf should have been represented this year. And Transformers was awesome, but big shiny robots aren’t that impressive in big shiny closeup. It’ll probably go to Pirates, because apparently Johnny Depp could take a shit on camera for two hours and people would be TiVoing that like Jesus’s return speech.
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
I Chose: No Country for Old Men
Who Should Win: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
I’m ashamed to say, I’m totally befuddled as to who to pick for screenplays this year. The Coens did great stuff with No Country. Diving Bell was transcedant. I think Blood will sweep this year, and I chose with my heart, as a true asshole. Atonement will probably snatch this up, because the source material was stronger.
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
I Chose: Juno
Who Should Win: Lars and the Real Girl
I loved Juno so much I wanted to take it behind the middle school and get it pregnant. It is my favorite movie of this year, hands down. But Lars and the Real Girl is a brilliant, unbelievably good script. It dances such a desperate and dangerous line between hokey and heartbreaking. That’s tight stunning writing. Johnny Depp needs to apologize to Ryan Gosling for taking his spot on the Lead Actor category. Right after apologizing to Josh Brolin for cockblocking him also. But Juno will win, because everyone wants to hear what Diablo Cody will say, which will no doubt be torn apart on the Interwebs tomorrow. Lord knows, I might even tear into it.