I haven’t seen a comic book storyline get raped this heartily since Brett Ratner rubbed his syphillitic dick over X-Men III: Season of the Witch. Understand this first and foremost, I loved every cheesy cornhole moment in the Dolph Lundgren version. So I had little hope that this would not suck harder than Thai hookers trying to gameshow their way out of servitude with a sleeve of golfballs and gardenhoses. And I was not let down.
Where to begin? Let’s see. Well, first we have Thomas Jane, who does a serviceable job of looking hurt a lot and scowling like Christopher Lambert. Seriously, when he wakes up from the coma after being gunned down and sports the beard, ask yourself whether or not he’s about to duel Brother Justin with a big ol’ butterknife.
Oh, villianwise. Hahahah. John Travolta impresses the fucking hell out of me. Every time he plays a villian in a big budget action movie, he manages to get even more cartoony and worse. It’s amazing. It’s like a scientific formula. And it’s always in relation to how unlikely his protagonist is to actually be in an action movie. First we’ve got Broken Arrow, against Christian Slater. Then, it’s Face-Off, against Nicolas Cage. (Which I won’t lie, it still makes me laugh how much scenery John Woo let’s them chew in between loading up dove gun-fights.) Then we’ve got Swordfish, versus Hugh Jackman. But in this one, he manages to be so lame, it’s like he’s channelling Andy Garcia and Armand Assante at the same time, and the resulting swarthiness induces a stroke. He kisses his dead son twice, presumably because he hoped for some tongue. It’s so lame.
Then we’ve got the plot, which offends me on three different imploding scales of WhatTheFuckery? First, the Punisher is a cop whose wife and children are murdered, and so he goes on a vigilante rampage, destroying the business of the criminal who did him wrong. He’s violent, and he’s crazy, and he doesn’t give a fuck. In this one, they literally wipe out a family reunion. Which is so over the top, I only forgive it because I got to see Roy Schieder with a shotgun again. Smile, you sons of bitches. But, then the Punisher goes to the cops and tells them he’s back. Frank Castle is dead, he should be a fucking ghost, that’s what makes him scary. He doesn’t confront the chief of police on City Hall steps in front of the press! Then, they decide that he’s not going to kill up everyone in sight, but instead, he gets involved in this HORRIBLE revenge plot that’s convoluted and supposed to get Travolta worse. He steals the wife’s car, and instead of driving it over her son, or into their house to kill all her cats, he sets up the henchman numero uno with it. With a fire hydrant. The Punisher should not have a fire hydrant unless he’s beating someone to death with it.
THEN, as if it weren’t enough, they send a bevy of more cartoonish henchmen to kill him. These are probably in the comic. Yeah, if it was going to be a series, then it’d be funny. First of all, the actors are not good. I love Kevin Nash and all, but I seriously wished the Russian was Dolph. But he dispatches them in incredibly cheesy ways. What the fuck was El Mariachi doing singing him a song? Was Spader and the Stopwatch not available?
Worst of all was the addition of the trio of mutants that share the fucking apartment building with him. Not only were they terrible, but they were useless, and did nothing but bespoil the plot. Ben Foster as some sort of pierced weirdo, John Pinette as a fat guy (because when is he not) and then Rebecca Romijn Lettuce as some sort of abused waitress. This part of the movie offended me the worst, not because of the forced romance, not because of the so-called cutesyness, but mostly the total flaming lack of logic. It just doesn’t make sense. Castle should have just killed them all.
This movie was so offensively plotted and overlong and disrespectful to the comic, that by the time he got down to business gunning up the baddies, I was already too mad to care. Yeah, yeah, he sticks a knife through a guy’s chin and you see the blade in his open mouth. One good scene in a movie that sucked is not a good movie.
I just hope Dolph Lundgren gets to kill them all in heaven.